Community Safety Initiative
Draft — open community review. Nothing here has been adopted. Any votes are a sentiment signal only — decisions happen in group forums (e.g. Loomio), not on this site. This tool is not legal advice.
Repercussion draft

SYN-016

Freedom is not freedom from consequences

Freedom of speech and expression does not mean freedom from consequences. Exclusion only looks punitive through a default-world lens; here it is framed as a capacity and sustainability limit — what the community can withstand while staying safe — and whether a person is unwilling or unable to change, the effect on others is the same. Mindful exclusion is deliberately different from the default world's "kicking people out".

Where this comes from · 7 source items

This draft merges what the community actually said across 7 source items — every source ID is permanent and traceable.

  • GTC-018 Freedom of Speech and Freedom of Expression is not Freedom from Consequences.
  • GTC-069 If people unwilling or unable to change, doesn’t make a difference. The effects are the same. Kicking people out feels default world. Mindful exclusion is different
  • OPIN-054 May seem punitive, but only from default world lens. There’s a higher standard of care here, which explains the need for policies
  • OPIN-074 Freedom of Speech and Freedom of Expression is not Freedom from Consequences.
  • OPIN-109 Framing in communities, exclusion happens for 2 reasons – capacity.- what can community withstand prior to exclusion or it will destabilize. Exclusion is “this is costing the system too much energy and not sustainable”
  • OPIN-117 What if someone is unable to change? If people unwilling or unable to change, doesn’t make a difference. The effects are the same.
  • OPIN-118 Kicking people out feels default world. Mindful exclusion is different

Themes · repercussions and exclusion · communication and tone

Your signal on this draft

Sentiment only — no action is taken from these tallies. You can change it any time.

Log in to comment or signal on this draft.

Comments · members only

Comments and tallies are visible to registered members. Log in.